Kant, Frege, and the normativity of logic:<scp>MacFarlane</scp>'s argument for common ground
نویسندگان
چکیده
According to what used be the standard view (Poincaré, Wang, etc.), although Frege endorses, and Kant denies, claim that arithmetic is reducible logic, there not a substantive disagreement between them because their conceptions of logic are too different. In his “Frege, Kant, Logic in Logicism,” John MacFarlane aims establish do share enough conception for this substantive, judicable dispute. maintains both fundamental defining characteristic “that it provides norms thought as such” (MacFarlane, 2002, p.57). I defend view. show MacFarlane's argument rests on conflating way pure general normative canon propaedeutic, once these distinguished blocked.
منابع مشابه
Frege and Carnap on the normativity of logic
In this paper I examine the question of logic’s normative status in the light of Carnap’s Principle of Tolerance. I begin by contrasting Carnap’s conception of the normativity of logic with that of his teacher, Frege. I identify two core features of Frege’s position: first, the normative force of the logical laws is grounded in their descriptive adequacy; second, norms implied by logic are cons...
متن کاملThe Argument of Possibility and necessity encountering the critiques of Russell, Hume, and Kant
The argument of possibility and necessity- which is considered as some of the most important arguments in proving the existence of God - have taken a key place in humanschr('39') thoughts. In history, among thinkers related to the creation of the universe, no major philosopher or thinker can be found other than those who have faced this argument; thus this argument has met many criticisms an...
متن کاملThe analytic-synthetic distinction and the classical model of science: Kant, Bolzano and Frege
This paper concentrates on some aspects of the history of the analyticsynthetic distinction from Kant to Bolzano and Frege. This history evinces considerable continuity but also some important discontinuities. The analytic-synthetic distinction has to be seen in the first place in relation to a science, i.e. an ordered system of cognition. Looking especially to the place and role of logic it wi...
متن کاملthe innovation of a statistical model to estimate dependable rainfall (dr) and develop it for determination and classification of drought and wet years of iran
آب حاصل از بارش منبع تأمین نیازهای بی شمار جانداران به ویژه انسان است و هرگونه کاهش در کم و کیف آن مستقیماً حیات موجودات زنده را تحت تأثیر منفی قرار می دهد. نوسان سال به سال بارش از ویژگی های اساسی و بسیار مهم بارش های سالانه ایران محسوب می شود که آثار زیان بار آن در تمام عرصه های اقتصادی، اجتماعی و حتی سیاسی- امنیتی به نحوی منعکس می شود. چون میزان آب ناشی از بارش یکی از مولفه های اصلی برنامه ...
15 صفحه اولذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
ژورنال
عنوان ژورنال: European Journal of Philosophy
سال: 2021
ISSN: ['0966-8373', '1468-0378']
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/ejop.12620